How Do You Know If You’re Really a Conservative?

October 7, 2015
Posted by Jay Livingston

Are Conservative Republicans a breed apart? And are they getting even farther apart?

A recent Pew survey compared attitudes a year ago and last month on the subject of abortion. The 2015 survey was done in the immediate wake of those now-famous videos of Planned Parenthood officials, videos shot surreptitiously and edited tendentiously. The demographic that showed the largest swing in opinion was Conservative Republicans.*

Among people who identified themselves as Conservative Republicans, opposition to abortion rose from 65% to 79%. Four out of five Conservative Republicans now oppose abortion. No other group in the survey comes in at more than half.

(Click on the image for a slightly larger view.)

The obvious explanation is that in the past year, an additional 14% of Conservative Republicans have become more conservative on abortion. The hardliners are becoming even harder. But there’s another possibility – that many of the Conservative Republicans who did not oppose abortion a year ago no longer call themselves Conservative Republicans.

That’s not as unlikely as it might seem. 


The Gallup poll shows that among Republicans, those who identified themselves as conservative on both economic and social issues – the largest segment of the faithful – dropped from 51 to 42 percent.  What if all the dropouts were abortion moderates?

I did some simple math.  I imagined 100 Republicans in 2014. Of those, 51 were self-identified conservatives, and of those 65% opposed abortion. That makes 33 who thought abortion should be illegal nearly all the time.

Last month, only 42 of those 100 Republicans said they were thoroughly conservative, 9 fewer than a year ago.  Of those left, 79% were anti-abortion. That makes 33. In my scenario, these were the same 33 as a year ago. The 9 who defected to the less-than-fully-conservative camps were the ones who were wishy-washy about making abortion totally illegal. Perhaps this is our old friend social comparison. These nine people looked at the hardcore, and the next time that a pollster asked them about where they stood politically, they thought, “If being a Conservative Republican means wanting all abortions to be illegal, maybe Im not so conservative after all.”



Conservative
Republicans
%Anti-
Abortion
Number Anti-
Abortion
2014
51
65%
33
2015
42
79%
33

I’m speculating of course. Besides, the data and calculations here are surely too simplistic; I am not a political scientist. But maybe the party purists are indeed forcing others who used to be close to them politically to rethink their identification as Conservative Republicans.


----------------------------
* The drop in support among those 30-49 and 50-64 does fall just outside the confidence interval of 5.5 points, but is only half as large as the change among conservative Republicans.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

You don't need to guess. You can figure out from the data the percentage of conservative Rep amongst all Rep because the percentage of Republicans who are against abortion is Percent_Rep_against_Ab = Percent_Cons_Rep_Against_Ab * Percent_Cons + Percent_Mod_Rep_against_Ab.
Thus you can figure out that in Sept 2014 77% of Republicans were conservative Republicans and in Sept 2015 69% of Republicans were conservative republicans.

Anonymous said...

Sorry I mean:
You don't need to guess. You can figure out from the data the percentage of conservative Rep amongst all Rep because the percentage of Republicans who are against abortion is Percent_Rep_against_Ab = Percent_Cons_Rep_Against_Ab * Percent_Cons + Percent_Mod_Rep_against_Ab*Percent_mod.
Thus you can figure out that in Sept 2014 77% of Republicans were conservative Republicans and in Sept 2015 69% of Republicans were conservative republicans.